POZ Community Forums
Meds, Mind, Body & Benefits => Questions About Treatment & Side Effects => Topic started by: bobsmth on November 30, 2012, 09:24:10 pm
-
I understand that most people that get the rash are able to work thru it and stay on Atripla. Any comments would be appreciated.
Bobsmth
-
Why do people still take Atripla with new drugs out there like Complera and Stribild? They have been shown to be just as effective if not more effective, and don't have the bad side effects.
Curious as to why you chose Atripla?
-
Rash usually last a day or two, if it hasn't already disappeared its prob just a day away.
-
Why do people still take Atripla with new drugs out there like Complera and Stribild? They have been shown to be just as effective if not more effective, and don't have the bad side effects.
Curious as to why you chose Atripla?
And why are you so anti- Atripla? You do know that both Complera and Stribild only recently came out (in 2011 and 2012, respectively) and maybe not everyone's insurance plan covers them?
Not everyone suffers horribly from taking Sustiva as you seem to think, as you're directing people away from Atripla based upon either your own personal experience, which doesn't apply to the population at large -- or things you've read. You do know that these treatments are NOT a one-size-fits-ALL deal and not everyone experiences the same results and/or side effects, just like any other medication?
-
Not everyone suffers horribly from taking Sustiva as you seem to think, as you're directing people away from Atripla based upon either your own personal experience,
It certainly isn't personal experience, he was only diagnosed on October 10th of this year. (See his "personal statement" under his username.)
Windy, as Solo points out, many people have NO problem with Atripla (or Sustiva). However, in addition to the fact that many people cannot yet get insurance for the newer meds (or they're not even offered yet in countries where hiv care is free), they're new and we don't really know all that much about possible side-effects yet.
I've had a LOT more time to think about what my initial treatment would be than you've had so far (over ten years as opposed to just over seven weeks) and while I decided to not go with anything containing Sustiva, I did go with an older, more established combo that has been shown through many people's experiences (certainly more than the two combos you seem to be championing) to be very tolerable for the vast majority. (Prezista, Norvir and Truvada)
Windy, I'm not being mean, but it would behoove you to sit back and learn more before you start making statements about that which you don't really know much about. OK? Thanks.
-
Hey thanks for replying, The Atripla was the ID Dr's. idea because of my poor numbers CD4 206 and viral load at 59,000. Might be me cause I couldn't stay on Bactrim because of the rash, tho this rash is much milder than the Bactrim one so far anyway.
-
It certainly isn't personal experience, he was only diagnosed on October 10th of this year. (See his "personal statement" under his username.)
Windy, as Solo points out, many people have NO problem with Atripla (or Sustiva). However, in addition to the fact that many people cannot yet get insurance for the newer meds (or they're not even offered yet in countries where hiv care is free), they're new and we don't really know all that much about possible side-effects yet.
I've had a LOT more time to think about what my initial treatment would be than you've had so far (over ten years as opposed to just over seven weeks) and while I decided to not go with anything containing Sustiva, I did go with an older, more established combo that has been shown through many people's experiences (certainly more than the two combos you seem to be championing) to be very tolerable for the vast majority. (Prezista, Norvir and Truvada)
Windy, I'm not being mean, but it would behoove you to sit back and learn more before you start making statements about that which you don't really know much about. OK? Thanks.
Since you completely misunderstood what I was trying to say, I'll break it down for someone who has been around so long maybe their thought process is a bit cloudy since you know so much.
What is the one common complaint you see about people on Atripla? The side effects. It seems like people may not do their research thoroughly enough and the default option always seems to be Atripla. Even you seemed to have some reason to stay away from the Sustiva back in your day, and went with a different option. You did your research. When I first started reading up, I too thought that Atripla was my only option, until I continued reading. My choice was confirmed when my doctor recommended I stay away from it for any possible side effects.
Granted not everyone experiences the side effects, and for them, that's great they have found a good treatment that works for them. For someone like the OP, I just hope he knows there are options out there.
In 10 years, will doctors look back at Atripla and shake their head that it was once the preferred treatment? Over the past 30 or so years, there have been several of those treatments that are now looked upon that way (AZT anyone). The reason I stayed away from Atripla was because of the possible side effects, I have zero clue if I would have even reacted badly to it. But by being able to choose a newer, safer treatment, I was able to avoid the what if's.
Finally, while you may have been around much longer, your condescending tone on here from time to time makes you sound more like someone to ignore. Just because you're good a reading stuff on the internet doesn't make you an expert, and neither does it most of us. You'd be better off helping when you can instead of making yourself feel good for being around so long.
-
And why are you so anti- Atripla? You do know that both Complera and Stribild only recently came out (in 2011 and 2012, respectively) and maybe not everyone's insurance plan covers them?
Not everyone suffers horribly from taking Sustiva as you seem to think, as you're directing people away from Atripla based upon either your own personal experience, which doesn't apply to the population at large -- or things you've read. You do know that these treatments are NOT a one-size-fits-ALL deal and not everyone experiences the same results and/or side effects, just like any other medication?
What people choose to take is their own decision, I was just curious as to why the OP chose it, and as he confirmed it was his doctors recommendation, not his. Since he is having the side effects, maybe it's good that he discover there are other options that will get rid of those side effects, and if he is able, maybe he can switch.
If someone is taking Atripla and it's working for them and they are happy, then keep on trucking! For this guy, I'm guessing he wouldn't mind getting rid of the rash.
If anything he now has something to investigate and see if it will work for him.
-
Windy - sassing the moderator being the sign of a shrewd operator, we're all awaiting your further pearls of wisdom... :o
(Is it drafty in here? I feel a draft.)
-
Oh, Windy's been like that ever since he first showed up. Completely not shocking.
-
Finally, while you may have been around much longer, your condescending tone on here from time to time makes you sound more like someone to ignore. Just because you're good a reading stuff on the internet doesn't make you an expert, and neither does it most of us. You'd be better off helping when you can instead of making yourself feel good for being around so long.
OK Sorry but I'm not about to sit and read rubbish like this and not say anything...Ann won't respond because she is a bigger and better person than I am.
Firstly, ignore Ann and you will find yourself in trouble, Ann has all the information that will help all those here to get through some very troubling times, seriously, if you have a problem Ann is the one to turn to, I know this first hand.
Secondly, Ann is an expert on HIV that is why she is here and has been since this site started...and it's time you showed some respect for those who really do know more than you, there was no need to respond in the manner you did.
Jan
-
Why do people still take Atripla with new drugs out there like Complera and Stribild? They have been shown to be just as effective if not more effective, and don't have the bad side effects.
Curious as to why you chose Atripla?
I had a horrific experience with Atripla, and combined with recent studies that suggest neuron damage (which might have added to other mental junk that I've had - and apparently it's manageable but not reversible) I understand the question.
Perhaps in a few years it, like other meds, it's formulation will change or it will be supplanted by other drugs that can penetrate the blood-brain barrier only without the CNS impact that it has - and I strongly suspect my experience is not nearly as uncommon as statistics have thus far indicated. It's always tough to tell whether a drug is causing suicidal ideation or whether the shock of testing positive or the "reality" of initiating meds causes a heretofore undiagnosed (or dormant) depression to arise.
It's not an evil drug by any means. I just think, and if the history of HIV medication is any indication, we can and eventually will do better.
-
Finally, while you may have been around much longer, your condescending tone on here from time to time makes you sound more like someone to ignore. Just because you're good a reading stuff on the internet doesn't make you an expert, and neither does it most of us. You'd be better off helping when you can instead of making yourself feel good for being around so long.
Um, Ann is well versed in reading "internet" things like scientific journals, which are available online. I believe she even subscribes to several first run journals as well. Trust me, she is not a lightweight when it comes to understanding the virus she has had for over a decade.
Ann, like Newt, Matty, and others, ARE HIV EXPERTS. I cannot stress that enough. You ignore them at your peril. As a matter of fact. Ann has helped draft several sections of this site's LESSONS, along with others.
And as far as changing a med because of a rash, with certain obvious exceptions (Ziagen) most rashes can be worked through and fade over time with prescription and/or OTC drugs. Changing a life-saving medication because of a temporary cosmetic issue seems a wonderful new luxury here in the world of AIDS 2.0
-
Changing a life-saving medication because of a temporary cosmetic issue seems a wonderful new luxury here in the world of AIDS 2.0
^^This should be posted in every single doctor's office for all those Vanity Sixers out there who want to change regimens because they noticed their eyes are jaundiced after having been on Reyataz for 36 minutes ::)
Sorry to hijack this thread, but I wonder what some of the newly diagnosed would do if they had to contend with side-effects from some of the meds that many of us here took in the past? I know I'd take a rash any day over being fearful that I'd shit my pants at any second (which I did on a few occasions at work) and then just accepting that it was better than the alternative of being in the ground. Shitty tight whities or dead? Hmmmm.
-
^^This should be posted in every single doctor's office for all those Vanity Sixers out there who want to change regimens because they noticed their eyes are jaundiced after having been on Reyataz for 36 minutes ::)
I absolutely agree with you that there are far worse side effects than jaundicing issues. If the comment was in any way directed at me (since you made remarks to me in the past about changing my meds) there is a huge difference between 36 minutes, and staying on Truvada/Reyatz/Norvir for four months, and still having a bilirubin level around 10. When I work with the public having people ask me EVERY DAY for four months why my eyes are yellow, it becomes a little bit more than cosmetic, it starts to become emotional/mentally draining. After being on Epzicom and Reyatz for two days the jaundice went away, and my viral load has dropped even further, so for me it was worth the switch. I'm all for sticking it out, and hoping that those 'minor' side effects will pass, but with me they didn't, so I switched and my quality of life has improved greatly in the last month.