TRIM5{alpha} defends against retroviral invasions could lead to "cure"?

[bimazek]

Anti-AIDS Protein Mechanism Found
 
By Kim Tae-gyu
Staff Reporter
 
A team of South Korean scientists has discovered how a protein, TRIM5, blocks the progression of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), which can develop into acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS).
 
The team, headed by professor Oh Byung-ha at Pohang University of Science and Technology, on Thursday said the findings would lead to the accelerated development of an AIDS cure.
 
AIDS refers to a collection of symptoms and infections resulting from the depletion of the immune system caused by HIV. So far there are drugs that slow the progress of AIDS but no cures. AIDS drugs remain expensive, out of reach for millions of patients.
 
``Scientists learned that TRIM5 helps fight HIV in 2004, but they failed to discover how the protein works against the virus,’’ Oh said.
 
``But we found a domain in TRIM5, called B30.2/SPRY, that blocks the progression of HIV and also brought to light the three-dimensional structure of the domain,’’ the 45-year-old said.
 
Oh projected that further research would lead to drugs to grapple with the incurable disease, which claims millions of lives each year.
 
``It will not happen overnight. I bet it will take a long time to develop such drugs. But this is a breakthrough in fighting AIDS,’’ Oh said.
 
The research will be featured in the next edition of Molecular Cell, a biology journal.
 
12-29-2006 08:29
 



Scientists close in on anti-HIV protein
Last Updated: Friday, December 29, 2006 | 11:16 AM ET
CBC News
 
Scientists in South Korea have isolated the part of a protein found in primates that blocks the progression of human immunodeficiency virus in apes.
 
The discovery could lead to the accelerated development of an AIDS cure, according to Prof. Oh Byung-ha at Pohang University of Science and Technology.
 
Previous studies had identified a protein called TRIM5 as being able to fend off retrovirus infections — like HIV — in monkeys.
 
Oh and his team of researchers now say they have further isolated a part of the protein that may be key to unravelling the monkey's defence mechanism.
 
"Scientists learned that TRIM5 helps fight HIV in 2004, but they failed to discover how the protein works against the virus," Oh told the Korea Times.
 
"But we found a domain in TRIM5, called B30.2/SPRY, that blocks the progression of HIV," Oh said.
Continue Article
 
The TRIM5 protein is also present in humans, and scientists have been investigating whether the human version of the protein can be altered to fight HIV.
 
Oh told the Times that further study of the domain will lead to drugs capable of handling the disease.
 
"It will not happen overnight," he said. "I bet it will take a long time to develop such drugs. But this is a breakthrough in fighting AIDS."
 
The research will be published in the next issue of Molecular Cell, a biology journal.
 
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome, or AIDS, is the name given to the collection of symptoms and infections resulting from depletion of the immune system caused by HIV.
 
Drugs exist to slow the progress of AIDS, but there are no cures for the disease. UNAIDS estimates 39.5 million people have HIV and 2.9 million would die from it in 2006   

How TRIM5{alpha} defends against retroviral invasions

Michael Emerman*

Division of Human Biology, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA 98109

The immune response to viral infections comes in two well described flavors. First, innate immunity [for example, natural killer (NK) cells and IFN responses] nonspecifically recognizes viral infections to trigger autocrine and paracrine signals that limit viral replication. Second, adaptive immunity (for example, T cells and B cells) specifically recognizes viral infections through secreted and cell-meditated factors. However, for retroviral infections, there is a third component of viral recognition and subsequent restriction that has been called "intrinsic immunity" (1). Intrinsic immunity differs from innate and adaptive immunity in that it is cell autonomous (does not rely on secreted factors), it is present in many cells (rather than only in specialized immune cells), it does not need to be induced by viral infections, and it probably evolves with viral infections on a longer evolutionary time scale than the innate and adaptive immune responses. Trim5{alpha} is a cytoplasmic protein that forms part of the intrinsic immune system that restricts retroviral infections in primates. This protein targets the viral capsid (CA) protein in a species-specific manner, but the mechanism of how Trim5{alpha} inhibits retroviral infections has been unclear. In this issue of PNAS, Stremlau et al. (2) address this important question by showing that Trim5{alpha} from rhesus macaques inhibits HIV type 1 (HIV-1) by direct recognition of the viral capsid protein followed by accelerated "uncoating" of capsid from the incoming viral particle.

The importance of the Trim5{alpha} gene was originally discovered by the Sodroski laboratory because it protects cells derived from Old World monkeys (OWM) from infection by HIV-1 (3). This gene encodes a protein that is a member of the tripartite motif family defined by the presence of RING, B-box 2, and coiled-coil domains (4, 5). In addition, Trim5{alpha} is part of the . .

see this diagram very interesting
http://www.pnas.org/cgi/content/full/103/14/5249/F1

Figure 1


Fig. 1. Proposed mechanism of Trim5{alpha}. HIV (at left) enters a cell by membrane fusion and deposits its core (yellow) containing viral RNA (red) and other viral proteins into the cytoplasm. Trim5{alpha} (green) binds to the mutimeric CA on the viral core and leads to accelerated uncoating (free CA monomers as yellow circles). This activity prevents reverse transcription (RT) of the viral RNA into proviral DNA.


























Published online before print March 27, 2006, 10.1073/pnas.0601373103
PNAS | April 4, 2006 | vol. 103 | no. 14 | 5249-5250


IS
COMMENTARY
How TRIM5{alpha} defends against retroviral invasions

Michael Emerman*

Division of Human Biology, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA 98109

The immune response to viral infections comes in two well described flavors. First, innate immunity [for example, natural killer (NK) cells and IFN responses] nonspecifically recognizes viral infections to trigger autocrine and paracrine signals that limit viral replication. Second, adaptive immunity (for example, T cells and B cells) specifically recognizes viral infections through secreted and cell-meditated factors. However, for retroviral infections, there is a third component of viral recognition and subsequent restriction that has been called "intrinsic immunity" (1). Intrinsic immunity differs from innate and adaptive immunity in that it is cell autonomous (does not rely on secreted factors), it is present in many cells (rather than only in specialized immune cells), it does not need to be induced by viral infections, and it probably evolves with viral infections on a longer evolutionary time scale than the innate and adaptive immune responses. Trim5{alpha} is a cytoplasmic protein that forms part of the intrinsic immune system that restricts retroviral infections in primates. This protein targets the viral capsid (CA) protein in a species-specific manner, but the mechanism of how Trim5{alpha} inhibits retroviral infections has been unclear. In this issue of PNAS, Stremlau et al. (2) address this important question by showing that Trim5{alpha} from rhesus macaques inhibits HIV type 1 (HIV-1) by direct recognition of the viral capsid protein followed by accelerated "uncoating" of capsid from the incoming viral particle.

The importance of the Trim5{alpha} gene was originally discovered by the Sodroski laboratory because it protects cells derived from Old World monkeys (OWM) from infection by HIV-1 (3). This gene encodes a protein that is a member of the tripartite motif family defined by the presence of RING, B-box 2, and coiled-coil domains (4, 5). In addition, Trim5{alpha} is part of the subset of this family that also contains a C-terminal B30.2 (SPRY) domain (Fig. 1). Expression of Trim5{alpha} from OWM either in its natural context or in heterologous cells inhibits the accumulation of new viral genomes that are the product of the viral enzyme reverse transcriptase. The human version of Trim5{alpha} is not effective against HIV but does inhibit a mouse retrovirus, N-tropic murine leukemia virus (N-MLV).


Figure 1
View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
     Fig. 1. Proposed mechanism of Trim5{alpha}. HIV (at left) enters a cell by membrane fusion and deposits its core (yellow) containing viral RNA (red) and other viral proteins into the cytoplasm. Trim5{alpha} (green) binds to the mutimeric CA on the viral core and leads to accelerated uncoating (free CA monomers as yellow circles). This activity prevents reverse transcription (RT) of the viral RNA into proviral DNA.

Using swaps of genes from related Trim5{alpha}-sensitive and -resistant viruses and also viral mutants, several groups identified the CA protein of retroviruses as the critical viral determinant for recognition by Trim5{alpha} (reviewed in ref. 6). Moreover, Trim5{alpha} restriction can be saturated by preinfecting cells with virus-like particles from a virus that is sensitive to the restriction but not with monomeric CA (7, . Thus, it was predicted that Trim5{alpha} recognized an epitope of CA that depends on the multimeric complex of CA formed only upon assembly of CA proteins into particles. Stremlau et al. (2) were able to demonstrate direct recognition (binding) of Trim5{alpha} for capsids by using a recombinant version of CA still fused to the nucleocapsid (NC) protein that was known to spontaneously form virus-like particles in vitro (9). This experiment confirms a previous report that had shown that human Trim5{alpha} could bind detergent-treated virions of N-MLV (10).

Because both virus-binding studies used Trim5{alpha} expressed in cell lysates (2, 10), it is still formally possible that there is an "adapter" protein that bridges Trim5{alpha} to viral capsids. However, this scenario is very unlikely because of the unusual genetics of restriction factors. That is, Trim5{alpha} shows strong evidence for positive selection in primates (11–13). Selection pressures that would lead to the accelerated evolution of Trim5{alpha} to recognize new viral infections that become endemic in a population are most simply explained by a direct recognition of Trim5{alpha} for new variants of CA. Indeed, the regions of Trim5{alpha} that have been identified as showing the highest amounts of positive selection in the B30.2 domain and, to a lesser extent, in the coiled-coil domain are those domains that confer specificity of restriction, and those two regions are also the two regions identified by Stremlau et al. (2) as being essential for the biochemical recognition of capsids by Trim5{alpha}.

When does Trim5{alpha} recognize the viral capsids? The stage of the viral life-cycle after entry into the cytoplasm but before completion of reverse transcription and entry into the nucleus is called uncoating, and it is thought that CA becomes dissociated from the viral particle shortly after entry. It has been proposed that this early uncoating step is essential for HIV to enter the nucleus before mitosis (14). Thus, for Trim5{alpha} to affect the virus after entry, it must affect the virus before it loses its capsid. Indeed, HIV-1 becomes resistant to restriction within minutes of infection (15). This result indicates that Trim5{alpha} acts at a very early stage of the viral life-cycle immediately after entry (Fig. 1).

Mutations in CA that both stabilize and destabilize the association of CA with the core affect reverse transcription (16). These results suggest that any cellular process that changes the kinetics of uncoating might affect reverse transcription. Thus, Stremlau et al. (2) considered three different possibilities regarding how rhesus Trim5{alpha} affects HIV uncoating: Trim5{alpha} could prevent uncoating, it could accelerate uncoating, or it could cause degradation of the capsids. This latter hypothesis was based on the E3 ubiquitin ligase activity of a shorter isoform of TRIM5, TRIM5{delta}, which depends on the RING domain that is present in both Trim5 isoforms (17). However, by using a sucrose gradient technique to capture intracellular CA protein and separate it into particulate (presumably still containing a higher-order structure) and soluble (disassembled) forms, they found that rhesus Trim5{alpha} does not cause an apparent proteolysis of HIV-1 capsids because bulk CA levels remain constant in the presence or absence of Trim5{alpha} (3). Rather, Trim5{alpha} causes a decrease in particle-associated CA. Significantly, they saw the same result when they examined the consequences of human Trim5{alpha} restriction of N-MLV. Because the association of CA with N-MLV is more stable than for HIV-1, they could directly follow the conversion of particle-associate N-MLV CA into soluble forms. Stremlau et al. (2) interpret these results to suggest that Trim5{alpha} executes its antiviral effects by disrupting what is usually an ordered process of uncoating and reverse transcription (Fig. 1).

How does Trim5{alpha} accelerate uncoating? The B-box and RING domains are essential for this effector (as opposed to recognition) function (18, 19). Because proteasome inhibitors had only a minor effect on the overall activity of Trim5{alpha} (2, 18), it is less likely that the ubiquitin-ligase activity of the RING domain is directly involved in degradation of a protein that holds the capsid together. Cyclophilin A, a peptidyl-prolyl isomerase, is important for the activity of rhesus Trim5{alpha} (20), and it is likely that other proteins are also involved in the process. The development of in vitro uncoating assays (16, 21) should shed light on whether Trim5{alpha} recruits factors that accelerate the usual uncoating process of HIV. One caveat to these speculations is that another form of Trim5{alpha} that is found in squirrel monkeys appears to exert its antiviral affect after, rather than before, reverse transcription (22). Thus, it is possible that multiple or alternative mechanisms of inhibition might exist.

What is the "normal" function of Trim5{alpha}? One could argue that it does not have one except as surveillance against retroviral infections because the rapid evolution of the gene (13) would mean that any normal function of the gene would also have to be evolving in parallel. Because the positive selection of Trim5{alpha} is centered on the B30.2 domain, it is possible that the other Trim5 isoforms that do not contain this domain (5) do have a normal function. However, this function is unlikely to be essential because there are humans with deleterious homozygous mutations in a conserved residue of a domain present in all of the isoforms (23).

Trim5{alpha} genes that have been cloned and tested from a variety of primates show that each one has a unique viral specificity, but in no case so far do they have substantial activity against retro-viruses that currently endemically infect that species. Because host populations evolve much more slowly than viral populations do, the recognition of a new virus will therefore always lag behind unless coincidental viral restriction already existed in the newly infected host. That is, the Trim5{alpha} that each species currently possesses protects that species from past infections (and possibly, serendipitously, future ones) but not current ones. Because nearly 8% of our genome is made of the relics of past infections in the form of extinct endogenous retroviruses (24), and because positive selection of Trim5{alpha} in primates dates back to >35 million years, some of these ancient events are presumably examples of prior episodes of Trim5{alpha} recognition and surveillance (13). Thus, our immunity to some retroviral infections endures far longer than any active immunological response. The elucidation of TRIM5 mechanism may facilitate pharmacological and genetic interventions to coax currently nonrestrictive human TRIM genes to target and restrict important pathogens like HIV-1.